The Upper Crust Menu (Update 2025)
The Upper Crust in Cedarhurst, NY, offers a diverse menu with kosher, pizza, and Italian options. From antipasti like Blue Fin Tuna Tartare to salads like Ahi Tuna Nicoise, the restaurant caters to a wide range of tastes. Quinoa bowls like the Mamilla Quinoa Bowl provide healthy choices. Customer reviews rave about the delicious food and excellent service, making it a popular spot for families and groups. The upscale yet casual ambiance, gender-neutral restrooms, and outdoor seating add to the overall experience. Despite some cleanliness concerns in the bathrooms, The Upper Crust stands out for its flavorful dishes and accommodating menu customization. If you're looking for a vibrant dining scene with top-notch food, The Upper Crust is a must-visit.
Antipasti
Corn Ribs
chili garlic rub, lime, cilantro, ranch drizzle.
$16.25
3 Cheese Ravioli Crisp
$16.25
Baked Italian Nachos
$22.50
Blue Fin Tuna Tartare
$25.00
Buffalo Poppers & Fries
$18.75
Cali Poppers
$18.75
Cauliflower & Broccoli Duo
$18.75
Grilled Cheese Romano
$17.50
Guacamole
$18.75
Loaded Potato Skins
$17.50
Mac N' Cheese Bites
$20.00
***Mini Cheese Calzones
$16.25
Mozzarella Sticks & Fries
$18.75
Nachos Veracruz
$22.50
Poke Tuna Nachos
$27.50
Pretzilla
$15.00
Quesadilla Formaggio
$17.50
Roasted Broccoli & Cheddar Melt
$20.00
Spicy Salmon Spring Rolls
$18.75
Spinach & Ricotta Cigars
$18.75
Truffle Fries
$15.00
Vidalia Onion Rings
$15.00
Mini Ahi Tuna Tacos
$20.00
Cauliflower Mac N Cheese
$20.00
Garlic Knots
$15.00
Ahi Tuna Nicoise
$31.25
Avocado Crisp Salad
$26.25
Beet Carpaccio
$25.00
Buffalo Chicken Salad
$27.50
Caesar Salad
$22.50
Cara Mia Salad
$25.00
Crispy Cauliflower Salad
$28.75
Halloumi & Mushroom Salad
$27.50
Mediterranean Salad
$23.75
Panzanela Salad
$23.75
Pecan & Pear Salad
$26.25
Poke Tuna Bowl
$31.25
Roasted Beet Salad
$26.25
Sweet Potato Salad
$26.25
Taco Supreme Salad
$25.00
Teriyaki Crunch Salad
$30.00
Upper Crust Salad
$25.00
Za'atar Salad
$25.00
Salads
Quinoa Bowls
Mamilla Quinoa Bowl
$28.75
Salmon Quinoa Bowl
$33.75
Southwest Quinoa Bowl
$31.25
Tuna Steak Quinoa Bowl
$32.50
Crunchy Thai Salad
$28.75
Wonderful Salad
$30.00
All Kale Salad
$25.00
Cryprus Salad
$28.75
Kale Salads
Quesodillas
Formaggio Quesodilla
$18.75
Roasted Veggie Quesodilla
$20.00
Spinach Cheddar Quesodilla
$20.00
Vegan Chipotle Chicken Quesodilla
$22.50
Soup of the Day
$11.25
Vegetable Soup
$11.25
Italian Onion Soup
$13.75
Soup
Sides
Fingerling Potatoes
$13.75
Sauteed Broccoli
$15.00
Sauteed Mushrooms
$13.75
Seasoned Fries
$11.25
Truffle Whipped Potatoes
$12.50
Vegetable Medley
$13.75
Zucchini Spirals (Side Dish)
$13.75
Side Salad
$13.75
Quinoa
$12.50
sourdough
$6.25
Baked Ziti
$28.75
Chicken Parmesan
$33.75
Eggplant Parmesan
$32.50
Fusilli Quattro Formaggio
$23.75
Lasagne Formaggio
$35.00
Pasta Al Forno
Spaguetti Squash
Spaghetti Squash
$31.25
Chicken Fajita (Copy)
$35.00
Tuna Steak Fajita (Copy)
$37.50
Chicken & Broccoli Quinoa Bowl (Copy)
$32.50
Fajitas
Pasta
Blackened Tuna Scampi
$28.75
Caprese Pasta
$26.25
Cheese Tortellini Tricolore
$30.00
Fettuccine Alfredo
$27.50
Fusilli Dell Ortelano
$25.00
Gnocchi Di Mamma
$28.75
Pappardelle
$27.50
Pasta Ragu
$23.75
Penne Alla Vodka
$25.00
Rigatoni
$30.00
Spaghetti Homestyle
$21.25
Three Cheese Ravioli
$30.00
Whole Wheat Pasta Primavera
$22.50
Zucchini Spirals
$27.50
Pad Thai
$30.00
Fussili Mac n Cheese
$27.50
Bronzino
$43.75
Sole Francese
$36.25
Crispy Fish & Chips
$32.50
Mahi Mahi
$36.25
Oreganata
$35.00
Gulf Red Snapper
$37.50
Blackened Tilapia
$33.75
Fresh Pacific Salmon
$35.00
Grilled Tuna Steak
$42.50
Tuna Steak Fajita
$37.50
Parmesan Crusted Halibut
$47.50
Alaskan Halibut
$47.50
Fish
Brick Oven Pizza
***Build Your Pie
$21.25
***DAVASH (NEW)
candied pecan, goat cheese crumble, baby arugula, vegan bacon, honey drizzle
$28.75
***Caesar's Favorite
$26.25
***Aglio
$25.00
***Bonta Verde
$26.25
***Quattro Formaggio
$23.75
***Spinaci
$26.25
***Funghi
$26.25
***Kalamata
$26.25
***Buffalo Pollo
$26.25
***Sunrise
$27.50
***Mac N Chees
$28.75
Bianco
Rosso
***Margherita
$21.25
***Pepperoni
$27.50
***Caprese
$23.75
***Jerusalem
$28.75
***Melanzana
$25.00
***Tuscan Bbq
$26.25
***Santa Fe
$27.50
***Spicy Chipotle
$28.75
***Carnita
$28.75
***Merguez
$27.50
***California
$30.00
***Gardenia
$26.25
***Low Carb Pizza
$21.25
***Broccoli Flower
$27.50
Americana Burger
$28.75
Broccoli Burger
$27.50
Cheddar Mushroom Burger
$31.25
New Englander
$28.75
Quinoa Burger
$27.50
Roadhouse Burger
$32.50
Salmon Burger
$28.75
Burgers & Sandwiches
Paninos
***Caprese Panino
$21.25
***Chello Spinach Panino
$21.25
***Eggplant Parm Panino
$21.25
***Broccolini Panino
$21.25
***Pesto Panino
$21.25
***Buffalo Vegan Chicken Panino
$21.25
Kids Pasta Fusilli
$15.00
Cheese Fries
$13.75
Pizza Fries
$16.25
Kids Menu
Milkshakes
Chocolate Milkshake
$10.00
Cookies n Cream Milkshake
$10.00
Strawberry Milkshake
$10.00
Vanilla Milkshake
$10.00
Fresh Brewed Coffee
$5.00
Cappuccino
$7.50
Cafe Latte
$7.50
Caramel Macchiato
$8.75
Cafe Americano
$5.00
Espresso
$3.75
Hot Choco Extreme
$7.50
Tea
$5.00
Hot Drinks
Iced Drinks
Chocolate Milk
$5.00
Iced Cappuccino
$8.75
Iced Caramel Macchiato
$10.00
Iced Coffee
$6.25
Iced Latte
$8.75
Iced Mochaccino
$10.00
Iced Tea
$5.00
Coke can
$3.75
Diet Coke bottle 20oz
$5.00
Gingerale
$3.75
Sprite
$3.75
Sprite Zero
$3.75
Orange Soda
$3.75
Canada Dry Seltzer
$3.75
San Pelegrino Seltzer can
$3.75
Small Pellegrino bottle
$5.00
Large Pellegrino bottle
$8.75
Sodas
Snapple
Lemon Snapple
$5.00
Peach Snapple
$5.00
Diet Peach Snapple
$5.00
Raspberry Snapple
$5.00
Diet Raspberry Snapple
$5.00
Iced Green Tea
$8.75
Iced Peach Passion Fruit
$8.75
Iced Raspberry Tea
$8.75
Iced Mango Tea
$8.75
Iced Lemon Tea (Sugarfree)
$8.75
Iced Tea
Water
Poland spring water 500ml
$3.13
Classic Limonana
$11.25
Strawberry Limonana
$11.25
Mango Limonana
$11.25
Passionfruit Limonana
$11.25
Lemonanas
Slushies
Classic Frappe
$12.50
Ala Mode Frappe
$17.50
Caramel Macchiato Frappe
$16.25
Mixed Berries Shake
$13.75
Strawberry Banana Shake
$13.75
Mango Shake
$13.75
Fruit Shakes
Main
Fresh Egg Omelet
$20.00
Homestyle Shakshuka
$22.50
Quesadilla with Tomato Dip
$20.00
Tuna Avocado Melt
$21.25
Ultimate Avocado Toast
$21.25
Jerusalem Omelet
$20.00
Breakfast Burrito
$20.00
Capresacado Wrap
$21.25
Tuscan Vegetable Wrap
$21.25
Salmon Caesar Wrap
$21.25
Tuna Wrap
$21.25
Veggie Burger Wrap
$21.25
Skinny Pizza & Salad
$20.00